I guess I'll do both caleian and BoomDraw just in an attempt to liven things up in here:
Caleian:
(Not sure if still active, but will do as if you are)
Points: 3/10 - you lost some villages recently but with five villages left it could definitely be worse
Tribe: 8/10 - doing a good job, secured K45 more or less, and got a solid core in the centre
Location: 4/10 - on the front line, no more barbs close by so only targets are bigger players
Farming: 5/10 - not the best but not the worst, can't say much else
Potential: 7/10 - think you had a lot of potential, unfortunately didn't stay too active for some reason
Total: 27/50, congrats.
Boomdraw:
Points: 7/10 - decent amount of points, and no lost villages
Tribe: 6/10 - never really get much attention from you guys, but I guess your points are fairly good
Location: 8/10 - nice location, decent room for growth, close enough to the frontline
Farming: 5/10 - same as above, could be better with the amount of barbs around you, but also could be worse
Potential: 8/10 - I think you'll carry on for a little while as long as you're active
Total: 34/50, nice one.