A public service announcement brough to you by IDC...

DeletedUser

Guest
.explosive noobs said:
If you are going to target barb munchers then why do you not start with your own, Dragonfly275, if you look at these nobles closer, you will find that out of a total of 10 conquers 5 have been barbs, so that is a 1:1 barb to players

Whereas the accused 'barb muncher' Dievas has only nobled 6 barbs out of a total of 28 conquers, so that is a 1.5:7 ,barb to player which is clearly a far better ratio of barbs to players than one of your own members, and Dragonfly probably isnt even the biggest barb muncher is IDC.

So please, when you are looking to flame someone for barb nobling, compare at least two accounts so a valid comparison can be made. Yes when stats are taken out of context they can delude opinions to be warped to your needs. My comparison although I only compare two accounts, it has far more validity than your obviously biased pathetic attempt at a PnP. :rolleyes:

Thanks for your time.;)
Daser.:D
Click to expand...

You fail to realise that there are other reasons that we are keeping the account in the tribe for the time being.
 

DeletedUser1446

Guest
He just compared the two players... If people come and write of OPTION C wrote it is normal that people start to compare...
 

DeletedUser

Guest
All i can see is IDC just booted only EX Creed Members. Allegation (nobbling barb) and wasnt following orders/rules. i can say they didnt follow the barb villas rules but except that they r following ever rules that have made from tribe.

AivarasLT Joined 19th April 2012 - 14:15 6,914
LeXiTe Joined 19th April 2012 - 09:13 15,717
Dievas Joined 19th April 2012 - 07:13 20,368
islah Joined 19th April 2012 - 06:13 10,514
Nierka16 Joined 19th April 2012 - 04:14 6,566


islah Left 16th May 2012 - 21:13 108,520
AivarasLT Left 16th May 2012 - 21:13 41,633
Aivareeenas Left 16th May 2012 - 21:13 44,039
Nierka16 Left 16th May 2012 - 19:27 68,258
Dievas Left 16th May 2012 - 19:27 181,315
LeXiTe Quit.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser1446

Guest
It is a good time for [GW] to join the world and make a bit fun of this perhaps...will think about it!
 

DeletedUser

Guest
explosive noobs, im not sure why you are trying so hard to create controversy here. Most if not all of the remaining IDC tribe supports the dismissals of these players; I can't say if their being from CREED had anything to do with it, but that's irrelevant.

Everybody not in IDC already hates IDC, so you don't have to change people's minds on that.

Look, the fact here is, all these players nobled low point barbs. Yes, others have too, but who knows the circumstances...

like dieva nobling 6 small barbs in a week... are you kidding me?
and islah, arguing on the public forums that nobling tiny barbs is okay even when told it is not probably didn't help you from getting dismissed.

yes, others in IDC have probably nobled low-point barbs, but maybe they had permission. maybe they apologized for it, or complied when told to stop. maybe they actually participated in the tribe, and were given a break; I don't think I can recall seeing any of the dismissed participate in the tribal forums with the exception of islah, who protested the dismissal of the others (and earning himself a dismissal).

Maybe the guys dismissed were discovered as spies for enemy tribes, or something else detremental to the tribe...

You can't really pretend to know exactly what is going on in leadership; hell, I'm in the tribe and have been playing with Matt, Caleb, and the others for a while now and I don't even know what is going on. I'm sure they have reasons behind this other than "Oh, they were from CREED."
 

DeletedUser

Guest
.explosive noobs said:
And I suppose you have another reason as to why sfinx is still in your tribe:rolleyes:
Click to expand...

If you want to pull that one off, please enlighten me as to why all of these guys are still in your tribe.
<table class="vis"><tbody><tr class="r1"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>14.Hatchery (497|537) K54</td><td>601</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>geniusjahyun [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-17 03:26:48</td></tr> <tr class="r2"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>10002 Calories (417|447) K44</td><td>336</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>Supersize This [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-16 15:24:04</td></tr> <tr class="r2"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>13.Gateway (495|605) K64</td><td>326</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>geniusjahyun [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-15 17:43:26</td></tr> <tr class="r1"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>12.Pylon (495|604) K64</td><td>388</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>geniusjahyun [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-14 17:39:38</td></tr> <tr class="r2"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>#Hey-Sourir-D-Enfer:D 8 (507|518) K55</td><td>767</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>CHEPULTURA [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-14 01:19:29</td></tr> <tr class="r1"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>Canelas Village #5 (509|509) K55</td><td>856</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>Meira4 [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-13 09:38:58</td></tr> <tr class="r2"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>Canelas Village #4 (494|512) K54</td><td>692</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>Meira4 [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-11 21:01:19</td></tr> <tr class="r1"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>004 (500|509) K55</td><td>592</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>ullf [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-11 08:44:16</td></tr> <tr class="r1"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>003 (498|512) K54</td><td>347</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>ullf [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-09 05:51:35</td></tr> <tr class="r2"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>Diestrus (510|548) K55</td><td>6,244</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>poly [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-08 22:54:11</td></tr> <tr class="r1"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>New York---006--- (483|565) K54</td><td>4,447</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>andy.110 [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-08 20:58:56</td></tr> <tr class="r2"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>Boom 6 (492|556) K54</td><td>425</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>outlaw982 [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-08 05:51:18</td></tr> <tr class="r1"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>002 (499|505) K54</td><td>615</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>ullf [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-07 16:27:28</td></tr> <tr class="r2"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>05 - Shadow (482|494) K44</td><td>2,701</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>RJShadowKnight [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-07 11:15:22</td></tr> <tr class="r1"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>#Hey-Sourir-D-Enfer:D 7 (496|504) K54</td><td>1,851</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>CHEPULTURA [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-06 08:02:50</td></tr> <tr class="r2"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>11.Armory (480|525) K54</td><td>667</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>geniusjahyun [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-04 23:33:18</td></tr> <tr class="r1"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>Boom 4 (490|557) K54</td><td>496</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>outlaw982 [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-04 19:58:47</td></tr> <tr class="r2"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>10.Control Tower (483|523) K54</td><td>397</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>geniusjahyun [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-04 12:49:53</td></tr> <tr class="r1"><td style="width: 10px">
green.png
</td><td>09.Starport (482|522) K54</td><td>479</td><td>Barbarian </td><td>geniusjahyun [Kitty?]</td><td>2012-05-04 00:03:03</td></tr></tbody></table>


Also, please don't take word from people that don't know what they are talking about. I'm not sure about the case behind Sfinx but he isn't being account sat as islah previously said.
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Yes, my tribe may noble more than their fair share of barbs, but at least we do not attempt to flame other players for barb munching when we ourselves are culprits of the same crime, hypocrisy comes to mind.
 

DeletedUser

Guest
.explosive noobs said:
Yes, my tribe may noble more than their fair share of barbs, but at least we do not attempt to flame other players for barb munching when we ourselves are culprits of the same crime, hypocrisy comes to mind.
Click to expand...


I can tell you exactly why your tribe has to noble barbs.

Cos you have Naped and allied the rest of the world so you can attack IDC. Which is fine for us, but it has completely stopped your growth and your ability to get a foot hold on your areas.

Your tribe cannot even attack 1 little player anywhere apart from Dahr555 which has cost leonrl 6 nobles and 4 days of attacks and 0 outside support and still hasn't got the village. And yet you think going to war with us and sending your nukes and nobles at me is going to get you somewhere? I think not.
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Hahahahaha yeah I agree. I'm sorry to say that Leonrl is an idiot... I've seen the reports and... *facepalm*

Dahr is still alive lawls.
 

DeletedUser

Guest
We at Idc, don't really care what any one thinks, whom may have been kicked for any reason. The fact of the matter is a barbie girl is a barbie girl. We invite you to show us otherwise on the battlefield and spare our precious farms.

IDC if you love me;]...
 

DeletedUser

Guest
islah said:
All i can see is IDC just booted only EX Creed Members. Allegation (nobbling barb) and wasnt following orders/rules. i can say they didnt follow the barb villas rules but except that they r following ever rules that have made from tribe.

AivarasLT Joined 19th April 2012 - 14:15 6,914
LeXiTe Joined 19th April 2012 - 09:13 15,717
Dievas Joined 19th April 2012 - 07:13 20,368
islah Joined 19th April 2012 - 06:13 10,514
Nierka16 Joined 19th April 2012 - 04:14 6,566


islah Left 16th May 2012 - 21:13 108,520
AivarasLT Left 16th May 2012 - 21:13 41,633
Aivareeenas Left 16th May 2012 - 21:13 44,039
Nierka16 Left 16th May 2012 - 19:27 68,258
Dievas Left 16th May 2012 - 19:27 181,315
LeXiTe Quit.
Click to expand...

Dievas ignored noble claims repeatedly and blatantly showed he had no intentions of respecting the noble claim system. I talked with Nierka repeatedly about this with basically no response, and with the consistent nobling of barbs by the entire group, it is better to just cut your losses and move forward. If I was to kick 1, the rest woulda followed regardless.
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Later on, nobling barbs is going to be required to win the game isn't it? ^^
 

DeletedUser548

Guest
They took that long to noble a semi-inactive account? And HE LOST HOW MANY TROOPS? Good lord... I think I need to go have a laugh... :D
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top